October 11, 2005

Dolly Parton -- Those Were The Days

Posted by Amanda Rose at October 11, 2005 12:39 AM

Dolly Parton
Those Were The Days
Sugar Hill

Firstly, what on earth is Dolly wearing on the cover? Some kind of .... boho Pocahontas meets the chorus line in Fiddler on the Roof thing. Of course Dolly Parton Can Do Whatever She Likes and Still Be Glorious -- of course, goes without saying --but it's a little, um, busy don't you think?

Also, on first glance the song list pains me intensely with its tweeness. Those Were The Days? Gah. If I Were A Carpenter? Meh.

Imagine? Kill. Me. Now.

If it sounds like I'm ready to snark at Miss Dolly, I'm really not. In fact, I rather wish I was her. No jokes please, I'm talking about her amazing totally-on-her-own-terms life and career, rock hard determination and ambition, endless ability to laugh at herself, and the all-encompassing fabulousness she radiates from every plasticised inch. Oh yeah, and the voice. True, the perpetually startled look on her face these days suggests a nip and tuck too far, but then Dolly has always been equally at home with her Dollywood fakeness and her Pigeon Forge authenticity. We wouldn't have her any other way.

And I do really like the album. Those Were The Days brings together Dolly's two worlds, the kitsch and the tradition. It's surely not "Islands in the Stream", but it's not quite the harder-core bluegrass of her last couple of brilliant albums either. Oh the banjos, mandolins and harmonies are there, mixed right up front but punters put off by the murder ballads and mournful mountain tales will find this a more upbeat and accessible affair. With guests like Rhonda Vincent and Dan Tyminski though, its old timey cred is intact.

The stand out for mine is "Me and Bobby McGee" with Kris Kristofferson noodling away there in the background, a rather spare bluesy take augmented with wailing harmonica. Love that wailing harmonica. Even those who find alot of the other songs here a bit cheesy will surely have to dig this.

Except for the annoying massed chorus, I also unexpectedly enjoyed "Where Do The Children Play", with Yusuf Islam on guitar. And call me profane, but the idea of a noted religious ascetic picking with the Texas Whorehouse lady herself really appeals to me. In fact, all of the numbers are real toe-tappers and I strongly suspect slipping it on after a little red wine will become irresistable. The major exception is Imagine, but frankly no one can rescue that one.

Keith Urban is rather wet on "Twelfth of Never" but otherwise the guests come through. I think for years I've been getting Nickle Creek and Rascal Flatts mixed up, for which I now apologise to the former. They and Dolly manage an affecting "Blowin' In The Wind", although I can't help really, really, really wishing she'd picked a less completely obvious Dylan song.

There's a little weirdness on the title track, in that it features the Moscow Circus. As you do. It was a bit of a thrill for a Russophile like myself to hear the boozy Russian singalong on the fade-out but it's a curious collaboration to say the least. *Shrug* I guess if Dolly wants the Moscow Circus, Dolly gets the Moscow Circus.

So, this is not down and muddy twang like I'd usually try to sell you on but Dolly has delivered a fun and delightfully cheesy slice of populist bluegrass which I defy you not to like, at least a little.

Now, where did I put that cab sav?

Comments

I think the Moscow Circus have had a contingent at Dollywood the last few years, maybe that's the connection.

Posted by: Uncle Tom at October 11, 2005 7:00 PM

To those of us who were sideswiped by the sixties, Dolly is dressed like the quintessential Love Child - a "look" seen from Haight Ashbury to Woodstock, and all points in between, from 1966 to 1970-something.

Of course, there are two very prominent differences.

Posted by: Jim Pipkin at October 11, 2005 7:04 PM

I'm sure that's the looks she's going for Jim. It's a bit all over the shop though.

Posted by: Amanda at October 11, 2005 7:38 PM

Okay, Amanda... I'm callin' you out, chica. I agree that folks could never adequately cover "Imagine," just like no one will ever be able to cover "Stairway to Heaven," nay, not even Dolly can get away with that travesty.

But deep down, "Imagine" and "Stairway to Heaven," no matter how over-played they might have been, are *damn* *good* *songs*. I will stand by that forever.

(And I don't think anyone could ever cover the "Star Wars" theme as well as Bill Murray either, but that's all I'm saying about that.)

Posted by: larry at October 11, 2005 10:33 PM

I just really dislike Imagine as a song, whoever is singing it. I admit part of this is because its been done to death, and the generally irksome effect John Lennon has on me, but really I find it shallow and stupid and people carry on as if it's this profound statement about the world when in fact it ... isn't.

I also dislike beetroot for no reason too. All part of the charm of me. ;-)

I do like Dolly's Stairway to Heaven though ...

Posted by: Amanda at October 11, 2005 11:23 PM

Amanda, I don't think you are taking into account the time during which "Imagine" was written. Lennon was light years ahead of what everyone else was writing about, and took it in the 'nads for that on several occasions.

To take on patriotism and organized religion all in one song was pretty meaty, especially when all everyone else was singing about was peace, drugs and poontang.

But it will either resonate or it won't.

Posted by: Jim Pipkin at October 12, 2005 12:10 AM

Well it was written numerous years after Dylan took on organised religion and patriotism (and With God on Our Side or Masters of War or Only A Pawn are far more in your face than Imagine.), still more years after Woody, Phil Ochs etc etc, songs which I love. It's not the that the issues don't resonate ... just not fussed about the song. It isn't a generational thing.

Posted by: Amanda at October 12, 2005 12:20 AM

PS. A little Googling re: Moscow Circus suggest Uncle Tom's speculation is correct.

Posted by: Amanda at October 12, 2005 7:49 AM

Definitely a subjective thing, I'm a Lennon fan, got a big poster and everything.

I never could listen to Dylan for more than three seconds at a time, great poetry, but that whiney nasal voice just HURTS. Tried to watch his latest biopic, had to mute the singing to get through it.

Yes, he's one of the Greats, but to me personally he just Grates. Rather listen to marbles in an Osterizer, accompanied by thousands of cicadas.

But I'd rather listen to Dylan than Yoko.

Posted by: Jim Pipkin at October 12, 2005 11:21 AM

Re Moscow Circus, well, I admit it was less speculation and more seeing Dollywood commercials on T.V.

Posted by: Uncle Tom at October 12, 2005 11:49 AM

Hmmm, I was on the side of larry and jim, until jim turned and took himself out with that last one on the Bobstar.

Posted by: cs at October 13, 2005 8:58 AM

I had a side?

Posted by: Jim Pipkin at October 13, 2005 11:26 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?