October 17, 2005

Domo arigato, Mr. Roboto

Posted by Stacy Chandler at October 17, 2005 7:24 AM

Oh, those crazy cats at Apple, always coming up with something new. Sometimes their obsession with innovation makes me mad, like when they abandon all support for their "old" iPods and stop making accessories for them way too soon. (For the love of God, my iPod is from 2002 -- it's not THAT old, not nearly old enough to get laughed at every time I take it out of my purse in an Apple store!) Also, not that this is my experience, but I'm guessing the folks who just ... bought ... a ... Nano ... are pretty steamed that Apple has already released something -- that video-playing doohickey -- to top it. Ouch.

But then sometimes Apple's great leaps forward make me happy. Like the recent iPod software update that finally made my elderly iPod able to shuffle songs randomly without me having to perform 17 sequential steps in five different menus before giving up and accepting that random shuffling will not happen until I get a Ph.D. Now I just scroll down to "Shuffle songs" on the main menu. Niiiice.

But Apple's newest tactic to part me from my money has me scratching my head. I speak of the "Just for You" feature on the iTunes music store. The idea, it seems, is to give recommendations based on your previous purchases. Kind of like what Amazon does, or really almost any online store, come to think of it. So it's hardly a startling idea, but, well, I'm startled. I'm startled because apparently iTunes thinks that since I purchased Robert Earl Keen's "The Front Porch Song," I would really dig something from "Whitney: The Greatest Hits." You know, as in Whitney Houston. Uh. Yeah. Only slightly less kooky is this: My husband bought "Simple Man" by Lynyrd Skynyrd, because recently, appallingly, we found we did not have it, despite hailing from Alabama (him) and Georgia (me). So iTunes thinks to itself, hmmm, I bet this person would really dig ... Jamie O'Neal, a frighteningly over-tanned pop country singer best-known for the decentish radio hit "There is No Arizona" and the hideous "When I Think About Angels." Hmm.

I guess this is what happens when you let a computer, or an algorithm (whatever the crap that is), try to make judgment calls on music. Just goes to show you robots can never really replace humans. Ha! Take that, robots. (NOTE: It is probably not a good idea for me to taunt robots, considering I live in Japan, world leader in robot technology. If you don't hear from me for a while, you'll know the robots came for me. It was nice knowing you guys.)

Now, a disclaimer: I just having some funs with ol' Apple. The other recommendations in the "Just for You" thingy (which IS labeled beta, by the way, so I imagine they're still working out kinks such as this mysterious Robert Earl Keen/Whitney Houston link) for me were pretty reasonable. For example, I bought a Rachael Yamagata EP on iTunes once, and now they're recommending a KCRW session. Well-played, as I wasn't previously aware of this live radio recording and now am thinking of buying it ("ka-CHING!" says Apple). So that's helpful. And I bought some White Stripes live thingy a while back, and ... HEY WAIT! The robots DID hear me, I guess. Apple seems to have detected I was making fun of it, and while I was typing that last bit my Music Store screen refreshed and now no more "Just for You" anywhere. Hmm. I'm, um. I'm going to go lock my doors now. Yes. And I should probably go ahead and start saving up for a new iPod, since I'm sure mine will blow up next time I try to update it. Grrrreat. See you.

Comments

Mmm, I was gonna wait till I got it in my feverish little hands before I mentioned it, but... the day after they announced the new iPods last week, I ordered me a 60GB black one. Oh yeah. And y'all will like the engraving on the back... I'll post pictures. ;-)

Screw the video... I could care less! But 60 gigs! With three times the battery life! And color screen! And it's all smaller than my current 20G! And it's probably 1/3 of the size of Stacy's Ruthie from 2002! HAH! I laugh at your 2002!

And I for one, would like to welcome our new robot overlords. I'd also like to note that I could be very helpful in rounding up certain "anti-robot" activists...

And for the record, the target market for the Nano was very different than the new iPod market. Folks who think "how will I ever fill up 2 or even 4 gigs of music" need a Nano. I know some of these sad, sad people. And then there are the sad, sad iPod people like me -- "Damn, how am I going to whittle down my 200+ gigs of mp3s into only 60 gigs!?!?!"

Posted by: larry at October 17, 2005 11:49 AM

That's right, yuk it up buddy! But don't come a-bellyachin' to me this time next year when your new 60GB mysteriously stops working and the Apple store workers laugh at you and advise you to just buy a new one. :P

Posted by: Stacy at October 17, 2005 10:24 PM

Wow. Your Just For You works better than mine. I bought Ray Charles Birth of Soul, and it recommends I buy an album by Rush.

Good to know about live Rachael Yamagata.

Posted by: Carlton Swift at October 18, 2005 9:55 AM

glad i dont have iTunes..sounds like it thinks we are all idiots and not able to choose our own music...i dont need a 'set of algorithims' to tell me what rocks..will stick with my laptop hard drive and a modest 512 that gets changed as often as my underpants...that is infact everyday folks...

Posted by: countrygrrl at October 20, 2005 5:29 PM

Apple should take a lesson from Amazon. Because Amazon often does me right with its recommendations based on previous purchases. It doesn't make outrageous leaps, but it does look for more obscure stuff I might not know about (and upcoming releases I might not know about).

Posted by: Sharon at October 23, 2005 2:01 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?