February 27, 2006

Pay the Devil (To Sit Through It)

Posted by Amanda Rose at February 27, 2006 3:39 PM

Pay the Devil
Van Morrison
Lost Highway (released 7th March)

The second time I listened to this album I didn't hate it quite as much as the first time. Who knows, if I gave it a few more spins I might make it to "indifference."

Van Morrison. Really great songs. Bombproof songs, really. A band with the necessary chops on paper. Why is this album so boring, and sometimes a baffling mess?

The band has a thin, tinny sound. The Nashville Sound strings and backing singers are generally heavy handed and weirdly placed. There are some instrumental breaks that actually sound like they are played by a human being but they're rare and only draw attention to the Casio Keyboard Backing Track Number 6 quality of the rest of it.

But these are good players so I guess we have to blame the producer who is listed as ... Van Morrison. Ahem.

Van himself is uneven and sounds unsure where to go on alot of the songs. He's good on "What Am I Living For" and "Till I Gain Control", OK on some others and terrible on "Once A Day." A really, truly terrible performance. That's particularly disappointing since it's one of my very favourite classic country numbers, but he rushes it out like he's following a bouncing ball. What's going on? Weird, I tell ya. It's all just weird.

I'd like to hear some live renditions of these songs before I completely write off the idea, the pieces are all there. Live maybe the band gets to break loose, and Van wakes up.

And maybe we've just been spoiled over the years by the rush of musicians paying homage to their influences. We've just accepted that a great artist with a great bunch of covers is going to deliver an album of rootsy magnificence. I like to think Van still can, but not with this disappointing mess.

Comments

This sounds like the album that Natalie Merchant did covering old folk tunes -- "The House Carpenter's Daughter." I thought... man, Natalie Merchant? Folk songs? Kick ass! But no, it was terrible.

I haven't heard the Van album, but I'm very disappointed that you're not liking it. I was hoping it would rock.

However, like the Natalie Merchant album, I'm forced to wonder -- is the album bad? Or do we just know more than is good for us? I mean, I kept wondering if the Natalie album made more sense musically to non-folk-music folks who liked Natalie. Maybe it was a "gateway drug" to get them into the harder stuff.

Kinda like Bela Fleck is for banjo music. He seems to get people over their "I hate banjo" hurdle, trains their ears, but then, if you're like me (and several of my friends), he gets really old really quick.

Thoughts?

Posted by: larry at February 28, 2006 11:41 AM

You're in luck if you wanna catch Van doing some country. He'll be here at the Ryman on Tuesday March 7th. I think tix are "off the hook", price-wise that is.

- Rob
Nashville, Tn

Posted by: Rob at February 28, 2006 1:27 PM

Hmmm no Larry I don't think so. I'm not above lighter fare, if these were just bog standard country covers to singalong to after a few beers I would have been satisfied. I haven't read any other real reviews of it (apart from three dismissive words oin a mailing list), I'd like to know if its just me or other people hear it the same way.

I don't think a country album from Van was ever going to pull in many new converts. His fan base would already be familiar with the genre I think.

Posted by: Amanda at February 28, 2006 2:26 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?