September 4, 2007
The highest of ups, the most beautiful of downs
Posted by Amanda Rose at September 4, 2007 6:39 PMTeddy Thompson
Upfront & Down Low
Verve
This is brilliant.
Teddy. I think I saw him at the Leonard Cohen tribute at the Sydney Opera House that one time. Being only a casual-though-academically-appreciative Richard Thompson person he didn't set off many lights. This has changed. We are lit up like a Christmas tree now, we are.
The way the Brits mail ordered the blues, took it apart and sent it back to the states is well known. The tradition of them doing it to country is much, much smaller of course. Much more obscure, in "side projects" and generally dribs and drabs over the decades rather than a Generation Defining Movement. But there's still probably a BBC audio documentary in it. I will listen to the most derivative and unoriginal country music and love it because ... the original is so good, why wouldn't I want to hear a copy? Low rent romance, second rate pastiche. It works.
However. This is not that. This is traditional country, thrilling on every front. Upfront & Down Low is a totally gorgeous album of only the absolute richest of countrypolitan sounds, but with other subtle and alluring touches. The strings are Nashville but sometimes very much not, those are very English violins. Just a hint, here and there. Lyle Lovett is a name mentioned in many reviews but surely we must also nod to Nick Lowe.
The Teddy tenor sells it all with heart rending sorrow and the band is perfect (including Marc Ribot and Thompson pere). Iris DeMent, Tift Merrit and Jenni Muldaur on harmonies. Some of the songs are the most familiar in the canon, like "She Thinks I Still Care" -- hard to do badly and of course he doesn't. The "secret track" is for mine the killer: "Don't Ask Me to Be Friends." Recorded by the Everlys and Cliff Richard in the 60s. and apparently no one else. Having sought out all extant versions on iTunes I can tell you Teddy's is the definitive and lifts it to classic status. Seriously, I've still got the stitches where it ripped out my heart and bounced it off the walls.
MUST I SHOW YOU THE SCARS?? HAVE I BEEN HYPERBOLIC ENOUGH? WILL YOU GO GET THIS RECORD????
No? Allow me to continue then. The other killer. "Down Low" is the only Thompson original and it perhaps has a vibe which stands out it its modern type of brooding fatalism but fits in with in the classic type of brooding fatalism which runs through country. Whipping out the Bob Luman novelty "Let's Think About Living" feels like a friendly in-joke and appropriate respite from the weeping. Chet Flippo says "the song rejects" Teddy's version of "(All My Friends Are Gonna Be) Strangers" but, that's in the ear of the beholder. For mine the song not only copes but positively prospers in this arrangement. It isn't a "British drawing room arrangement" actually, but someone needs to tell him your average British drawing room holds more perverted secrets, thwarted desires and unspoken despair than a David Lynch box set.
Last year Van Morrison released a country album. I didn't like it much, although a lot did. This is was hoping for, all that and more.
Yay! I've missed Amanda! Sweet review... and by the way, seeing *anyone* at the Sydney Opera House (which you mention so casually) is a big dream of mine...
Posted by: larry at September 4, 2007 10:46 PMI agree. This is a fantastically classy album. It's been a staple of my daily airplay since it's release.
I was impressed with his previous (debut) album, but it seemed to missing something collectively. Then his cover of Cohen's "Tonight Will Be Fine" from the concert you mentioned, made me determined to pick up his next offering. Up Front and Down Low is strong start to finish and demands consecutive replays. It's black tie country music without a trace of condescension pointed as us hillbillies. Sure, you'll notice that the fiddles have been traded in for violins, but his effort to give the music real dignity resonates track to track. It may be blasphemy, but IMO he stole "She Thinks I Still Care" from the Possum and made it his own...
Posted by: Alan at September 7, 2007 11:03 AMVery well put indeed, Alan.
There is are a very few songs that are structually so completely perfect that you can hear any number of versions and never feel compelled to pick between them. Some songs shrink in reinterpretation, others just endlessly expand and She's Thinks ... is one of those for me. So, the more the merrier.
Posted by: Amanda at September 7, 2007 8:30 PMI agree with you about the hidden track. The other absolute classic for me on this album is "My Heart Echoes." Absolutely beautiful. Made me go and find out who the Bailles Brothers are, too. This is country the way it should be!
Posted by: marybeth at February 26, 2008 11:24 AM